Since joining the Lisa Diemer Agency in Fall 2022, I’ve supported the team with organization and customer service. As admin and marketing specialist, I schedule appointments and boost client engagement. Outside work, I enjoy time with my husband, twins, and our cat Meeka—traveling, amusement parks, and family movie nights.

Caitlin Rutten is a seasoned marketing expert who loves memes, puns, and helping amazing people find the Lisa Diemer Agency.

I have been a licensed assistant to Lisa for over 25 years and enjoy helping clients with their insurance needs. In my personal life, I cherish spending time with my family, listening to audio books and always enjoy a good laugh. My family and I are devoted hockey fans, keeping positive that that the Columbus Blue Jackets will one day bring the Stanley Cup to Columbus.

With 25+ years in insurance, I’m proud to serve as a licensed Property & Casualty agent at the Lisa Diemer Agency. I help customers understand coverage and make informed choices. I’m detail-oriented, creative, and dedicated to personalized service. Outside work, I enjoy dining out, rock concerts, art, gardening, and cheering for The Packers!